By Dr. SamiUllah, PhD, Lead Formulator, Formula Chemistry
Quick Answer: A baking soda toothpaste is built around sodium bicarbonate at 35 to 45% of the formula, balanced with a carrier oil, a humectant, and a binder to prevent separation.
Learning how to make toothpaste with baking soda means managing three variables specifically: its low Relative Dentin Abrasivity of around 7, its alkaline pH near 8.0 to 8.5, and its tendency to settle out of a paste without a proper binder. Get those three right and the result is a stable, effective, single-abrasive paste.
Why Baking Soda Deserves Its Own Formula, Not a Shortcut Recipe
Most online recipes treat baking soda as an ingredient you dump into melted coconut oil and stir. That approach produces a paste that tastes overwhelmingly alkaline and separates within a week.
Sodium bicarbonate behaves differently from other abrasives, and a formula built specifically around it needs to account for that. This guide gives you a complete, weighed formula rather than a rough approximation, along with the reasoning behind every percentage.
If you’d rather work from a more balanced, multi-abrasive base first, our guide on how to make natural toothpaste covers the broader formulation logic this recipe builds on.
The Chemistry of a Baking Soda Toothpaste

Why Sodium Bicarbonate Behaves Differently From Other Abrasives
Sodium bicarbonate, CAS 144-55-8, has a Relative Dentin Abrasivity generally cited around 7, among the lowest of any common toothpaste abrasive. That makes it gentle on enamel even at a fairly high percentage of the formula.
Its drawback is taste and pH, not abrasion. A formula pH of 8.0 to 8.5 reads as distinctly alkaline and salty on the tongue, which is why balancing it with sweetness and flavor matters more here than in a calcium-carbonate-based paste.
Particle Size Changes the Feel More Than the Percentage
Fine-milled sodium bicarbonate produces a smoother paste with less grit. Coarser food-grade baking soda, the kind sold for baking rather than cosmetic use, can feel noticeably gritty even at the same percentage.
Sourcing a cosmetic or micronized grade makes a measurable difference in mouthfeel. This is one detail most home recipes skip entirely.
Solving the Separation Problem
Baking soda is a fine powder with no natural affinity for oil, so it settles to the bottom of a jar within days without a binder. Xanthan gum, CAS 11138-66-2, at 0.5 to 1.5% of the formula, suspends the powder and keeps the paste homogenous through the life of the batch.
The mechanism and dosing range for xanthan gum in cosmetic systems more broadly are covered in our piece on xanthan gum for skincare stability and hydration, and the same suspension principle applies directly here.
| Ingredient | Function | Weight % | Amount (g) |
|---|
All amounts are by weight. Weigh every ingredient, including liquids, on a scale accurate to 0.01 g.
The Complete Baking Soda Toothpaste Formula
This batch totals exactly 100.00% and is formulated as an anhydrous paste, so no preservative is required.
| Phase | INCI Name | Common Name | Percentage |
| A: Abrasive | Sodium Bicarbonate | Baking soda | 40.00% |
| B: Carrier | Caprylic/Capric Triglyceride | Fractionated coconut oil | 22.00% |
| B: Humectant | Glycerin | Vegetable glycerin | 18.00% |
| C: Binder | Xanthan Gum | Xanthan gum | 1.00% |
| D: Active | Xylitol | Xylitol | 10.00% |
| D: Flavor | Mentha Piperita Oil | Peppermint essential oil | 0.75% |
| D: Flavor | Stevia Rebaudiana Extract | Stevia extract | 8.25% |
| Total | 100.00% |
To scale to a 60-gram batch, multiply each percentage by 0.6. That gives 24g baking soda, 13.2g fractionated coconut oil, 10.8g glycerin, 0.6g xanthan gum, 6g xylitol, 0.45g peppermint oil, and 4.95g stevia extract.
Fractionated coconut oil was chosen here over whole coconut oil because it stays liquid at room temperature and carries the bicarbonate evenly. Its behavior as a lightweight carrier is detailed further in our article on fractionated coconut oil for lightweight moisture.
Glycerin’s humectant pull does double duty here, preventing the paste from drying out and softening the alkaline edge of the bicarbonate on the tongue. Its broader hydration mechanism is explained in our guide to glycerin as a hydration booster for skin and hair.
Mixing the Batch, Step by Step
Weigh the sodium bicarbonate and xylitol first, then whisk them together in a dry glass bowl until evenly blended. Sift the mixture if you notice any clumping in the baking soda before combining.
In a separate container, disperse the xanthan gum into the glycerin slowly, stirring continuously as you add it. Adding xanthan gum too quickly causes it to clump into gel beads that never fully dissolve.
Combine the glycerin and xanthan mixture with the fractionated coconut oil, stirring until the texture looks uniform and slightly thickened. Fold the dry powder blend into this oil phase gradually, in two or three additions rather than all at once.
Add the peppermint oil and stevia extract once the base paste has fully come together. Transfer the finished product into a clean, dry jar or squeeze tube and label it with the date it was made.
Six Mistakes That Ruin a Baking Soda Toothpaste

Using the full amount of baking soda with no buffering ingredient.
A formula that’s nearly all sodium bicarbonate tastes harsh and salty in a way most people find unpleasant daily.
Balancing it with xylitol and stevia, as in the formula above, keeps the taste manageable without diluting the cleaning function.
Skipping the xanthan gum step.
Formulators sometimes assume the oil phase alone will keep the powder suspended, and it won’t. Properly dispersing 0.5 to 1.5% xanthan gum before adding the oil is the fix.
Sourcing baking soda from the baking aisle instead of a cosmetic-grade supplier.
Standard food-grade baking soda often has a coarser particle size that reads as gritty in a paste. A finer, cosmetic-grade sodium bicarbonate produces a noticeably smoother texture.
Overloading the peppermint oil to mask the taste.
Increasing essential oil percentage above 1% to cover bicarbonate’s alkaline flavor introduces its own irritation risk to oral tissue. Adjusting the sweetener ratio solves the taste problem more safely than raising the essential oil level.
Storing the finished paste somewhere warm and humid.
Even an anhydrous formula can absorb ambient moisture in a steamy bathroom over time. A tightly sealed jar or tube kept away from direct shower steam holds up considerably longer.
Assuming a higher percentage of baking soda always means better cleaning.
Past a certain point, more sodium bicarbonate mainly adds taste intensity, not cleaning performance. The 35 to 45% range in the formula above already sits near the practical ceiling for a comfortable daily paste.
Who This Formula Suits and Who Should Be Cautious
This recipe suits anyone comfortable with a distinctly alkaline, salty flavor profile who wants a single-abrasive, low-RDA daily paste. It works well for people specifically drawn to baking soda’s reputation for a deep-clean feel.
It’s a poor fit for anyone with sensitive teeth who finds high-pH products uncomfortable, since the alkalinity here is more pronounced than in a calcium-carbonate-based paste.
Those users are usually better served by the milder, multi-abrasive formula in our natural toothpaste guide, or by our coconut oil toothpaste recipe if a more oil-forward feel is preferred.
Anyone with a diagnosed dental condition should consult a dentist before switching to any DIY oral care formula. Always conduct a 48-hour patch test with any new formula before wider use.
Common Questions About Making Baking Soda Toothpaste
Is baking soda too abrasive for daily toothpaste use?
No, sodium bicarbonate has one of the lowest RDA scores of any common abrasive, generally cited around 7. What people notice as harshness comes from its alkaline pH and taste rather than physical abrasion.
Why does my baking soda toothpaste taste too salty?
This usually means the bicarbonate percentage is too high relative to the sweetener content. Increasing xylitol or stevia slightly, rather than reducing baking soda, often solves it without weakening the formula’s cleaning function.
Can I skip the xylitol and stevia?
You can, but the paste will taste noticeably more alkaline and less pleasant without them. Both ingredients also contribute mild sweetness that offsets bicarbonate’s natural flavor.
Does this formula need a preservative?
No, because it’s formulated as an anhydrous paste with no free water content. A preservative becomes necessary only if you convert the formula to a water-based system.
How is this different from the natural toothpaste master formula?
This recipe uses sodium bicarbonate as the sole primary abrasive at a higher percentage, producing a more alkaline, saltier paste. The master formula blends calcium carbonate and baking soda for a milder, more balanced result.
What’s the shelf life of a homemade baking soda toothpaste?
Stored in a sealed container away from moisture, this anhydrous formula typically holds up for 6 to 12 months. Discard the batch if you notice any change in smell, color, or texture.
Can I use this formula if I have sensitive teeth?
The low RDA makes it gentle on enamel, but the higher pH can feel uncomfortable for some sensitive-tooth users. A patch test and a short trial period are the best way to check individual tolerance.
Is fine or coarse baking soda better for this recipe?
Fine, cosmetic-grade sodium bicarbonate produces a noticeably smoother paste than coarse baking-aisle product. The percentage stays the same either way, but the mouthfeel changes considerably.
The One Adjustment That Fixes Most Baking Soda Pastes
Nearly every failed baking soda toothpaste traces back to one of two things: a missing binder or an unbalanced sweetener ratio. Fix those two variables before changing anything else in the formula.
Weigh every ingredient on a gram scale rather than estimating by spoon, since bicarbonate’s fine texture makes volume measurements unreliable. Once the ratios above are dialed in, the rest of the process is simple assembly.
